Promotion of the Year
Pro Wrestling Guerrilla
-Runner-up: Insane Wrestling League
Wrestler of the Year
Kevin Steen
-Runner-up: Scorpio Sky
Most Outstanding Wrestler
Scorpio Sky
-Runner-up: Akira Tozawa
Tag Team of the Year
RockNES Monsters
-Runner-up: The Young Bucks
Rookie of the Year
Duke
-Runner-up: Angel Lopez
Match of the Year
Super Dragon/Kevin Steen vs. The Young Bucks – PWG – 12/10/11
-Runner-up: Adam Pearce vs. Colt Cabana – NWA Hollywood – 03/06/11